Friday 12 December 2014

"You can prove anything with facts"

Quite a few of my friends have political opinions. Most of them are just that, but it doesn't stop them spouting them as if they were true. Including me. Although I tend to be fairly intuitive with my diatribes and insights, that doesn't stop me from being right.

You can see where I'm getting this style from, can't you?

But seriously. The lies wash them down and the promises rust. Most of us instinctively distrust politicians. Why? Because our sub-conscious brains register their shifty eyes, the turn of their heads or downcast and sidelong glances when they are telling us lies, mis-truths or omissions.

Rhetoric and spin my friends, a diet our screens and airwaves cram down our willing and oblivious throats, and we are all too happy to shrug and move on with cries of "they're all a bunch of charlatans, but what can you do?"

I was thinking about the deficit today. Not that exciting as a source of amusement, but what I was mostly thinking about was that our TV experts really understand very little. That's because they are reading most of it, and my subconscious recognises when someone is talking to me like I'm an idiot. But my conscious "I used to work on the front-line of middle class goes south in the early 90s recession south-east London banking personal debt crisis" brain also knows its stuff.

So I know a few things about money and its rules. Of which there are two:

1. Don't spend more than you earn or sooner or later you will run out of cash and be in the shit.

2. It's generally better to know how and when the shit is coming, that way you may be able to prevent it. Keep honest records. At least for yourself.

So here's a question for you. How much is total public sector revenue this year? Or how about this one. Is the total public debt as a percentage of public revenue, going up or down?

I bet you don't know. I didn't. And you can bet your bottom euro, the politicians are not going to waive the numbers in your face. In fact I bet half the MPs in the House of Commons don't even know. Bet they believe their own lies. Governments don't have much influence because world forces shape our economy. And those are driven by the influence of capitalism.

So I went and did some digging around and found a website that has done the heavy lifting, and it allows you to create your own datasets. If you have a mortgage, chances are that when you took it out its total value was somewhere between 3-4 times your annual income, but over time as your income increased and the debt came down, that percentage would decrease.


All figs in billions GBP200620072008200920102011201220132014201520162017
revenue488519549536516555577593585648670690
spending523549582633673694694694713731747747
Annual surplus (deficit)-35-30-33-97-157-139-117-101-128-83-77-57
Total Public debt420490530620760910110011851258135514391497
GDP130014051450140714321499154615751641172917891860
debt as % of annual income86%94%97%116%147%164%191%200%215%209%215%217%
debt as % GDP32%35%37%44%53%61%71%75%77%78%80%80%

Not so our public debt. It's been rising faster over the last eight years than at any time since the second world war. That's not a partisan comment. I don't think governments of any political colour have the courage to take bold decisions, so in thrall are they to vested interests. The figures in blue are estimates of the future, which generally turn out to be bollocks.

The site also tells you that most of the spending goes on welfare, health and education, which to all intents and purposes are either politically untouchable or very hard to shift without mass starvation or riots on the streets. And that's just the over 50s.

So in a nutshell, unless we can make some very tough choices on spending, or start to improve incomes and hence tax revenues, we're in that proverbial. We have never faced anything like this before.

So you will hear lots of rhetoric and spin, but most of it will be guff. Which is why they are actually happy for the conversation to be all about immigration or terrorism. It's more simplistic and easy to appeal to all your opinions. Although quite frankly, without a big influx of young people in the next few years, I'm not sure who is going to pay for all my healthcare.

An answer? From me? Seriously? Well I wouldn't start from here for a start.

Here it is then.

5 comments:

  1. They used to make that boy shout and scream, but the over 50 Weller simply wants to die playing on stage. So no solutions there. I always wonder who we owe this debt to? Can we not simply use the weapons we spend some of it on to go and park on their doorstep and get the debt cancelled?

    ReplyDelete
  2. It turns out that we borrow money from pension funds to pay state pensions and they use the interest the Govt pays them to pay pensions. Young Weller only knew the half of it.

    Peter Maxwell Davies: Lullabye for Lucy (1981): http://youtu.be/T-lNb7KmF28

    ReplyDelete
  3. Brill post by the way - if this is the shape of 'rouleur posts to come, I'm all in favour.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Finally
    go here
    http://markwadsworth.blogspot.co.uk/
    or here
    http://www.yppuk.org/p/manifesto.html
    or here
    http://kaalvtn.blogspot.co.uk/p/index.html

    for more Georgist fun!

    ReplyDelete
  5. The only thing I understood was the bit about it being a load of bollocks ;)

    ReplyDelete